Secular Koranism story on Jews being too afraid to rank the four Gentile religions

     TABLE OF CONTENTS  

Below is a story about Orthodox Jews in a Secular Koranist America who hesitate to rank the four Gentile religions (Islam, Christianity, Hinduism, and Buddhism) by their conformity to the Noahide Laws due to fears of sparking antisemitism, and how the Secular Koranist government pressures them into compliance through a provocative shaming tactic. This narrative draws on all the data provided on Secular Koranism—its definition, laws, the Secular Koranist Constitution, the SKPA Party Constitution, the SKPA Manifesto, and various pamphlets—while reflecting the system’s unique dynamics and the Jewish community’s internal conflict.

---

The Reluctant Judges

The synagogue in Brooklyn was a fortress of quiet that June evening in 2025, its stained glass dim under the weight of a decision. Rabbi Eliyahu Stern stood before his congregation—fifty Orthodox Jews, men in black hats and women in modest skirts, their faces taut with unease. The Secular Koranist Party of America (SKPA) had ruled for over a year, its Secular Koranist Constitution reshaping the nation. No usury, a flat 20% tax, and a citizens’ militia had won some nods, even here. But tonight, the focus was the State Registry of Religions—and the burden it placed on them.

Eliyahu held a letter from the SKPA, its words stark: “Orthodox Jews, verified by synagogue membership and rabbinical vouching as free of the Torah’s 36 capital offenses, are tasked with ranking the four Gentile religions—Islam, Christianity, Hinduism, Buddhism—by their adherence to the Noahide Laws. This is your role, a secular contribution to statistical insight.” The Noahide Laws—seven universal commandments: no idolatry, no blasphemy, no murder, and so on—were their heritage, a gift to humanity. The SKPA saw them as a “seven-star rating service” for righteousness and cohesion, hoping Islam would rank highest, Christianity lowest for its Trinity. But Eliyahu’s flock wasn’t eager to play judge.

“We can’t do this,” said Miriam, a schoolteacher with sharp eyes, breaking the silence. “Rank Christianity as idolatry and blasphemy? Call Hindus pagans? It’s a match to dry grass—antisemitism’s already simmering. They’ll say we’re lording over them, like we run this Koranist state.”
Yosef, a wiry tailor, nodded. “I’ve seen the graffiti—‘Jews and Muslims rule now.’ If we rank them, they’ll hate us more. History’s proof—blame the Jews when things get tense.”
Eliyahu sighed. “The state says it’s not law, just data. No penalties. Freedom of religion holds—Koran 2:256, ‘no compulsion.’ But they want our voice.”
“Then let them rank themselves!” Miriam snapped. “Why us? We keep Shabbos, we study Torah—why risk our safety for their game?”

The fear was palpable. Antisemitism had flared since the SKPA’s rise—whispers of “Koranist Jews” controlling the flat tax, the slavery system for the poor, the militia. The registry’s split—Orthodox Jews vouched by Rabbis, Heretical Jews self-identified—already set them apart. Ranking Gentiles felt like painting a target. Eliyahu shared their dread. He’d seen the pamphlets: “Orthodox Jews evaluate for insight, not power.” Fine words, but words didn’t stop fists or torches.

Days later, an SKPA official arrived—David Klein, a lean man in a gray suit, flanked by a militia guard. The synagogue’s back room hosted the meeting, Eliyahu and ten elders facing Klein’s calm stare. “Rabbi Stern,” Klein began, “your community’s silent. We’ve asked for your rankings—Islam, Christianity, the rest. Why the delay?”
Eliyahu straightened. “We fear backlash. Call Christianity idolatry for its Trinity, and they’ll march on us. Rank Islam high, and they’ll say we’re Muslim puppets. Antisemitism’s a spark away—this could ignite it.”
Klein tilted his head. “It’s data, not doctrine. No one’s punished. Claire Khaw’s agnostic—this isn’t faith, it’s science. You’re in the registry for a reason: your expertise.”
“We’re not afraid of data,” Yosef cut in. “We’re afraid of mobs. History doesn’t lie.”
Klein’s eyes narrowed, a faint smile curling. “History, yes. But what about faith? You’re Orthodox—Torah-observant, believing in the World to Come, yes? The afterlife?”
Eliyahu frowned. “Of course.”
“Then why cower?” Klein pressed, his tone sharpening. “If you refuse this, you’re saying you don’t trust HaShem’s promise. You’re making the sentiments of Christians, Hindus—Gentiles—your idol, bowing to their feelings over your duty. Is that your faith? Fear their wrath more than God’s will?”

The room stilled. Yosef’s jaw tightened. Miriam glared, but her lips stayed shut. Eliyahu felt the sting—shaming, clever shaming. Klein wasn’t wrong about their belief: the afterlife, divine justice, was their anchor. To shrink from this task could be read as doubt, a betrayal of their own principles. Yet the risk loomed—practical, human, real.
“It’s not idolatry to protect our lives,” Eliyahu said slowly. “The Torah values peace, too.”
“Peace through strength,” Klein countered. “The state protects you—militia, courts. This isn’t 1930s Europe. Rank them, and we’ll handle the fallout. You’re not alone.”

The elders debated late into the night after Klein left. “He’s goading us,” Miriam said. “Calling us faithless? It’s a trick.”
“But he’s right about the state,” Yosef admitted. “No pogroms yet. The militia’s kept order—flat tax helps, too. Maybe they’d shield us.”
Eliyahu wrestled silently. The SKPA’s secular promise—no compulsion, no penalties—held so far. The Koranist laws hadn’t touched their Shabbos, their kosher kitchens. But this ranking felt like a ledge over a pit. Still, Klein’s words gnawed: idols of Gentile sentiment. Was fear their master now?

A week later, Eliyahu drafted the rankings, hands trembling over the parchment:

• Islam: 7 stars—pure monotheism, no idols, strong courts.
• Buddhism: 6—no murder, ethical, but godless.
• Hinduism: 5—moral codes, yet many gods.
• Christianity: 3—Trinity as idolatry, blasphemy against God’s unity.

He submitted it to the SKPA, heart pounding. The state TV aired it days later, a dry voice reciting: “Orthodox Jewish evaluation, for statistical insight only.” The synagogue braced. Graffiti appeared—“Jew Judges”—but no mobs came. The militia patrolled tighter. A few Christians protested downtown, signs reading “Jesus Is Lord,” but it fizzled.

Eliyahu exhaled, uneasy but relieved. The shame had worked—they’d ranked, and the sky hadn’t fallen. Yet as he davened that Shabbos, he wondered: had they dodged antisemitism, or just delayed it? The Secular Koranist state had their back—for now. But fear lingered, a quiet shadow in the sanctuary.

---

Notes on the Story

• Data Integration: The story uses Secular Koranism’s registry (Orthodox Jews’ role), Noahide Laws as a ranking tool, the SKPA’s hoped-for order (Islam high, Christianity low), and laws (no usury, militia), alongside its secular ethos (Koran 2:256, Claire Khaw’s agnosticism).
• Conflict: The Orthodox Jews’ fear of antisemitism reflects historical trauma, clashing with the SKPA’s pressure, mirroring pamphlet details on their evaluative task.
• Shaming Tactic: The government’s challenge—implying cowardice and idolatry—leverages their faith against them, a strategic twist fitting the SKPA’s pragmatic, order-driven approach.
• Resolution: Their reluctant compliance, with muted backlash, balances realism with the system’s protective claims, leaving tension unresolved.

This tale captures the Orthodox Jews’ dilemma under Secular Koranism—caught between duty and danger, prodded by a secular state wielding their own beliefs as a spur.